Tough call for the top... or bottom spot... pending on what's your peculiar sexual perversion. Anyway, it's a battle for that spot as JJ and Illini always seem to be trying to out gay the other. First, honorable mentions to TT for being the creepiest gay with his thread asking about black children playing in the street late at night... WTF?! Minny with his obsession with getting pixs of Sunny... yuck! And talking about Sunny, guess the gayish scale would depend on how you look at whether you view Sunny as a girl or guy. If a girl, then isn't she gay, but definitely helps out Minny. But if a guy, Minny moves up on the scale.
Now for the spot of the gayest! Definitely JJ is in the running with his obsesion with guys in general, asking about their physical features, age, where are you from and at, and requesting pictures of yourself; and basically seems like every other JJ's thread has some homosexual innuendos. If he just reverse that gay effort, he would be banging girls everyday... well, with his looks it be at least once a week.
The only poster that can top that off is Illini. I mean listening to some of his stories make me shiver. I'm in the mecca of gay, SF, and seen crazy gayish shit such as the Folsom Street Fair... think leather and chaps. (And no I didn't attend but they takeover all of SOMA area of SF and when you come out of the bar you can't miss them.) I'm almost positive Illini been to several of them. And the Power Exchange... don't know why a straight guy would go to something like that... yikes! Living in SEA, which probably has the highest concentration of ladyboys, I gotta say by a slighest of margin, he's the gayest. Oh yeah, and the obession w/ dick pixs... enough said. But the gayish is lower with him because he used to drink at the same SF bar that I used to drink at... Union Square Sports Bar. I always wonder if I saw him and didn't even know that was him. For that, much props but it doesn't negate all that gay shit. Illini by a shade of gay!