Skip to content

NFL 2025 Hall of Fame class

Top Sportsbooks

9.9

Bovada

75% Cash Bonus
Read Review
9.8

BetOnline

100% Free Play
Read Review
9.6

Heritage Sports

100% Free Play Bonus
Read Review
9.6

BetAnySports

30% Cash Bonus
Read Review
9.5

Everygame

100% Cash Bonus
Read Review
9.5

Bookmaker

25% Cash Bonus
Read Review

BigJay

-

BigJay

Joined
Oct 28, 2021
Messages
17,093
Only four get in

CB Eric Allen, DE Jared Allen, TE Antonio Gates, WR Sterling Sharpe

Smallest class in 20 years


 

BigJay

-

BigJay

Joined
Oct 28, 2021
Messages
17,093
Eli and Kuechly are a couple that were left out that were predicted by many to get in.

Especially Eli despite his only having above-average career stats
 

djefferis

-

djefferis

Joined
Jan 8, 2024
Messages
3,326
Gates deserved it.

Sterling Sharpe deserved it - great career cut short.

Eric Allen hasn’t made it in what - a couple of decades? Good player - but what changed this year ?

Jared Allen again very good - but a lot of guys who deserve to be in Lyle Alzado and LC Greenwood for example - Gastineau too. A lot of the argument for HOF is stats based for him and unfair to older guys.
 

djefferis

-

djefferis

Joined
Jan 8, 2024
Messages
3,326
Eli and Kuechly are a couple that were left out that were predicted by many to get in.

Especially Eli despite his only having above-average career stats

Kuechly was a beast.

If Eli wasn’t a Manning - would we even be having this conversation ? He won a couple of super bowls - ok, good on him. Championships alone don’t make a QB HOF worthy - especially when they were surrounded by top talent everywhere.

Nice guy and he will get in eventually likely - but for me just above average. Yes - there are plenty of others in who are comparable- but that is not justification to open the doors to anyone who exceeds the stats of someone who barely snuck in themselves.
 

BigJay

-

BigJay

Joined
Oct 28, 2021
Messages
17,093
Next year’s class will be larger

First-time eligible guys who will get in for sure:

Drew Brees
Larry Fitzgerald
Jason Whitten

and coach Bill Belichick

Also Frank Gore and Rivers first time eligible
 
Last edited:

BigJay

-

BigJay

Joined
Oct 28, 2021
Messages
17,093
Kuechly was a beast.

If Eli wasn’t a Manning - would we even be having this conversation ? He won a couple of super bowls - ok, good on him. Championships alone don’t make a QB HOF worthy - especially when they were surrounded by top talent everywhere.

Nice guy and he will get in eventually likely - but for me just above average. Yes - there are plenty of others in who are comparable- but that is not justification to open the doors to anyone who exceeds the stats of someone who barely snuck in themselves.
Agree on Kuechly

One of those guys I loved watching play

He will get in eventually you have to think
 
Top