I think everyone will agree he's already the best shooter to ever play so another championship definitely puts him in the top 10 if he wasn't already there on someone's list, but is Top 5 pushing it?
I take out bill Russell and Jerry west because I never saw them play and have very little frame of reference. Russell over rated for winning championships in a league of 8 teams, and as a rookie he had like 5 other hall of famers on the team that drafted him. I also take out tim Duncan for lack of star/wow factor. Oscar played in point inflation days, so he is gone too.
yeah I wouldn't argue much with Shaq over Durant. Moses with his rebounding domination and defense stays up there for me though. he prob drew even more fouls than Shaq and MADE his free throws. the fact that Shaq never really improved that weak spot, which is easily the easiest skill to improve upon will always limit his greatness in my mind.
The best shooter ever at this time but not even close to being the best ever. Every era has their players. Imagine if Steph was playing against the bad boys of Detroit back in the day. Snapped in half comes to mind.
MJ and Lebron (basically a tie at #1 for me)
Kareem
Magic
Wilt
Russell
Bird
Those are the only guys I think I'd put ahead of him, and I think it's actually debatable between him/Bird. Impact on the game is greater than most on that list too.
Can't really go wrong. They're definitely the top 2
LeBron's longevity and performance in playoffs is pretty remarkable when you really dive into it. He was also remarkably efficient in clutch situations, something that is historically overlooked because of stereotypes of him not looking to score enough. He was also the better overall playmaker and far superior passer
I truly believe if you've been fortunate enough to see both of them play, that it's very easy to see that there is no comparison and that there's MJ, and then everyone else.
Not only in overall talent and heart and killer instinct, but the aura of Michael in general