Skip to content

Bill Belichick not a first-ballot Hall of Famer

BigJay

BigJay

Joined
Oct 28, 2021
Messages
25,241

djefferis

djefferis

Joined
Jan 8, 2024
Messages
4,463
Bottom line - HOF is for players.

Coaches should be viewed as “contributors” and not on the ballot. They have a direct effect on the outcome of every play potentially - but no matter how well drawn up the play - they rely on someone else to execute it.

Just like coaches rely on owners and GM’s to provide them with the $$ and cap space to acquire talent and picks - the coach is a contributor.
 

djefferis

djefferis

Joined
Jan 8, 2024
Messages
4,463
Pro Football HOF is almost as big of a joke as the basketball HOF anyway with the voting process.

Multiple rounds and every year your guaranteed 4 - but never more than 8 inductees.

So if you retire after a lean few years you have a better chance - but retire the same year as a couple of first ballot candidates and your caught in a numbers game with the leftovers.

Its simple - your either worth or your not. Should be 70% - not 75% or 80% and there should be a fan ballot after the writers have theirs giving fans the opportunity to vote if the writers miss someone.
 

Archie

Archie

Joined
Nov 8, 2021
Messages
9,238
the writers vote,?

he wasn't really a fan of the writers and vice versa so that might be part of it too
 

BigJay

BigJay

Joined
Oct 28, 2021
Messages
25,241
Interesting. Kraft is not in either. I wonder if Kraft, Chapel Bill, and Brady are a package deal on being non first timers even though they will all eventually get in.
Brady will be eligible in 2028.

He will obviously be first ballot. Went outside “the family” and won his last. If he’s not first ballot no one should be.
 

pipe

pipe

Joined
Aug 3, 2022
Messages
10,994
It's very clear to see they cheated. 😧
 

seaborneq

seaborneq

Joined
Aug 7, 2022
Messages
2,432
Brady will be eligible in 2028.

He will obviously be first ballot. Went outside “the family” and won his last. If he’s not first ballot no one should be.
Brady is still a part of spygate and deflategate, plus he busted his phone when the heat was closing in, in addition he was suspended 4 games for it. It only takes 10 votes to hold him back. I think the reason he took the TV gig is to rehab his sneaky image.
 
Top