Which of these 4 is the WORST QB?

[DiggityDaggityDo]

 

[lekidecincinnati]

manning not enough playoff success

 

[edawg]

Patrick

 

[Wagerallsports]

Patrick

I agree

He’s still playing so still much to be seen

Also, take away one of the best coaches all time in Andy Reid, and Mahomes probably doesn’t have a single Ring

 

[JDS]

Joe Montana

 

[DiggityDaggityDo]

Joe Montana

 

[JDS]

View attachment 75316

1. Tom Brady 97.2 (7 Rings)
2. Patrick Mahomes 101.9 RTG (3 Rings)
3. Peyton Manning 96.5 RTG (2 Rings)
4. Joe Montana 92.3 RTG (4 Rings)

I give 3 extra RTG points per ring so that gives Joe Montana 98.3 & Peyton Manning over 100 RTG.

 

[BobbyFK]

Joe simply didn't have the same impact as Manning, Brady or Mahomes

• He played fewer games (192) than any of the others (Brady: 335, Manning: 266, Mahomes: 117 and counting).
• His 40,551 career yards and 273 TDs are great, but they're a fraction of the numbers Manning and Brady put up, and Mahomes is already close to his TD total in about half the games.

 

[JDS]

Joe simply didn't have the same impact as Manning, Brady or Mahomes

• He played fewer games (192 starts) than any of the others (Brady: 335, Manning: 266, Mahomes: 117 and counting).
• His 40,551 career yards and 273 TDs are great, but they're a fraction of the numbers Manning and Brady put up, and Mahomes is already close to his TD total in about half the games.

Good info Bobby I agree

 

[lekidecincinnati]

Joe simply didn't have the same impact as Manning, Brady or Mahomes

• He played fewer games (192) than any of the others (Brady: 335, Manning: 266, Mahomes: 117 and counting).
• His 40,551 career yards and 273 TDs are great, but they're a fraction of the numbers Manning and Brady put up, and Mahomes is already close to his TD total in about half the games.

what about quality over quanity
4 for 4 superbowls

 

[JDS]

1. Tom Brady 97.2 (7 Rings)
2. Patrick Mahomes 101.9 RTG (3 Rings)
3. Peyton Manning 96.5 RTG (2 Rings)
4. Joe Montana 92.3 RTG (4 Rings)

I give 3 extra RTG points per ring so that gives Joe Montana 98.3 & Peyton Manning over 100 RTG.

Actually, my math is wrong here LMFAO

So I change my answer to Peyton Manning.

 

[jjgold]

Manning

 

[BigJay]

Joe Montana

That’s who I voted for

All four great obviously but you put Tom, Peyton and Patrick on those 49er teams and they have the same success

Not sure I can say the same about putting Joe on the Pats, the Colts, or the Chiefs

 

[JDS]

That’s who I voted for

All four great obviously but you put Tom, Peyton and Patrick on those 49er teams and they have the same success

Not sure I can say the same about putting Joe on the Pats, the Colts, or the Chiefs

Oh, I ended up changing my answer because of my rating system, slightest of edge Joe over Peyton.

 

[jamesy2422]

brady is indisputable and manning was cerebral. manning would have had more championships without brady.

mahomes changed the chiefs. take him away and they suck.

i loved montana as a kid but the three above have changed the qb position.

 

[Tanko]

Mahomes.

I think you have to consider the era each has played (is playing) in.

Tom's the GOAT
Montana to Rice is just too nice not to be #2.
Peyton was one smart SOB.
Mahomes still growing even with the SB rings.

 

[Franz555]

Mahomes

As Wager stated , not enough to compare to the other 3

Jerky are you Mad ? Joe Montana read the game better then any QB ever......

Im with Diggity

Slap that man

 

[pipe]

Peyton