Aaron Judge Greatest Player Of This Generation

[phillyflyers]

Your're making stuff up, cool

Make what up?

Last season he hit 54 Homers, his career high. Before that, his best season was 46.

That's 2 seasons of his best not counting his outlier.

 

[fishhead]

You're assuming judge injury free OHTANI not, lol

Ohtani hit 54 homers last season and stole 59 bases, lolol................98 homers last 2 years

 

[fishhead]

Both neck & neck

Wrong, Ohtani better

 

[fishhead]

You're assuming judge injury free OHTANI not, lol

Ohtani hit 54 homers last season and stole 59 bases, lolol................98 homers last 2 years

59 of 63 SB............wow!

.................and pitches.

 

[phillyflyers]

Judge light years better.

Look at the numbers.

 

[fishhead]

Bad look for you here Flyer

 

[phillyflyers]

Last season...

Judge 559 AB

144 RBI 58 HR

Sushiboy 636 AB

130 RBI 54 HR (Career High)

Judge gives more production with less at-bats.

There is no metric where Sushiboy is better than Judge.

 

[rickeyphillips]

If Judge came up a few years earlier he’d finish all time HR leader. He’s going to tail off. My guess two, maybe three prime years left. I think three might be pushing it.

 

[phillyflyers]

If Judge came up a few years earlier he’d finish all time HR leader. He’s going to tail off. My guess two, maybe three prime years left. I think three might be pushing it.

I don't see him tailing off.

He keeps in top shape year round.

His power is always going to be there.

 

[fishhead]

Bad look for you here Flyer

bump

 

[str]

Nice to see that Judge isn’t labeled with a racist slur like Ohtani is.
Progress ?

 

[rickeyphillips]

I don't see him tailing off.

He keeps in top shape year round.

His power is always going to be there.

He’ll be 34 in the opening month of next years season. Father Time is undefeated. His bat will slow down a tick and it’ll be over. You think he’s hitting 45 bombs at age 37? No way. He’s got two maybe three prime years left.

 

[fishhead]

He’ll be 34 in the opening month of next years season. Father Time is undefeated. His bat will slow down a tick and it’ll be over. You think he’s hitting 45 bombs at age 37? No way. He’s got two maybe three prime years left.

Ohtani 25 months younger and on pace for same homers as Judge......... and 38 wins and 614 K's as a pitcher already in the bank.

 

[rickeyphillips]

Ohtani 25 months younger and on pace for same homers as Judge......... and 38 wins and 614 K's as a pitcher already in the bank.

Ohtani isn’t a pimple on Judge‘s ass. Stop.

 

[fishhead]

LOL

 

[drunkenhorseplayer]

Stop acting like Sushiboy is some.kimd of Hall of Fame type pitcher.

Very mediocre with little real value.

19 games over .500 for his career on a team that regularly won 40, 50, and even 60+ more games than they lost during the course of a season.

Not that great of winning percentage all things considered. A 3 ERA is also mediocre.

Judge has offensive numbers that are at historic levels.

Your argument is Sushiboy can pitch.

Well his pitching can't make up for the Grand Canyon sized rift in offense between him and Judge.

Judge is in his own universe. Period.

A 3.00 ERA is mediocre? In this era, a career 3.00 ERA for a starting pitcher is uber-elite. Ohtani's pitching or hitting numbers alone would make him a potential HOFer, the fact that he can do both makes him the all around GOAT.

 

[phillyflyers]

A 3.00 ERA is mediocre? In this era, a career 3.00 ERA for a starting pitcher is uber-elite. Ohtani's pitching or hitting numbers alone would make him a potential HOFer, the fact that he can do both makes him the all around GOAT.

Yes, he's uber-elite pitching 1 game a season

Meanwhile, Judge is rewriting the record books.

Sushiboy isn't close and the numbers reflect that fact.

 

[drunkenhorseplayer]

How many games is Judge pitching every season?

 

[phillyflyers]

How many games is Judge pitching every season?

I've already addressed this multiple times.

Judge is at HISTORIC levels. Sushiboy isn't doing anything historic.

His pitching isn't great enough to value him over the impact of Judge.

 

[KingKolzig]

Honestly age not factored id take pete crow-armstrong over judge

Incredible defense where judge is like having gronk in right field. PCA will end up bat .275 with 40+ homers and 40+ stolen bags

Then on defense amazing

And he went nuts last nite. Shut me up