Skip to content

This is a first in MLB I'm sure/ Ex-MLB player Darin Ruf files lawsuit against Reds

Top Sportsbooks

9.9

Bovada

75% Cash Bonus
Read Review
9.8

BetOnline

100% Free Play
Read Review
9.6

Heritage Sports

100% Free Play Bonus
Read Review
9.6

BetAnySports

30% Cash Bonus
Read Review
9.5

Everygame

100% Cash Bonus
Read Review
9.5

Bookmaker

25% Cash Bonus
Read Review

BigJay

BigJay

Joined
Oct 28, 2021
Messages
18,867

Tanko

Tanko

Joined
Oct 27, 2021
Messages
51,428

BMR Genie

BMR Genie

Joined
Jun 16, 2016
Messages
37,566
Most lawsuits don't state an actual amount, they'll make a claim such as " in excess of $$ " or compensatory to earnings in year x y z" thus leaving a judge or jury to decide compensation & punitive, if any.
I see.. that makes sense.

Do you think his value at the time of his career will get him good money for this case, Minny?
 

209life

209life

Joined
Feb 13, 2023
Messages
1,620
Former MLB player Darin Ruf is suing the the Cincinnati Reds over a tarp he claims caused his career-ending injury two years ago, according to the Associated Press.

The lawsuit was reportedly filed Thursday in the Hamilton County (Ohio) Court of Common Pleas. It reportedly accuses the Reds of negligence for failing to maintain safe field conditions, specifically noting the risks presented by an unpadded metal tarp roller at Great American Ball Park.

Ruf encountered that tarp while playing first base for the Milwaukee Brewers on June 2, 2023. He tracked a foul ball toward the first-base stands and hit the tarp hard, leaving him with a deep laceration in his right knee and a non-displaced patella fracture.

His lawsuit reportedly describes the damage as “permanent and substantial deformities to his knee.”


Ruf attempted to return later that season, hitting .120 in seven games on a rehab assignment with the Triple-A Nashville Sounds, but never played in another MLB game. He did not sign with a team after becoming a free agent that winter.

He now blames the Reds for leaving a large metal object in the field of play, via the AP:

“This didn’t need to happen,” Ruf said in a statement. “I wish it didn’t happen. Players shouldn’t have to worry about hidden hazards like that on a major league field.”
His lawyer said the same:

“This was an obvious and avoidable risk,” Tad Thomas, Ruf’s attorney, said in a release announcing the lawsuit. “There are basic safety protocols every MLB team should follow. Leaving an unpadded metal roller on the edge of the field is inexcusable.”
Ruf played a total of nine seasons in his MLB career. He began his career mostly as a bench bat at the corners for the Philadelphia Phillies before moving to South Korea's KBO and finding immense success with the Samsung Lions.

That success continued upon Ruf's return to MLB, as he enjoyed the two best seasons of his career with the San Francisco Giants in 2021 and 2022. He was one of many over-performing bats that powered the Giants to a 107-win season that unseated the Los Angeles Dodgers in the NL West.

Ruf struggled after that, in stints with the Giants, Brewers and New York Mets across 2022 and 2023. It was unclear how much further he could have gone while hitting .224 in his age-36 season, but no player wants to end his career like he did.
 

djefferis

djefferis

Joined
Jan 8, 2024
Messages
3,666
Reading what both Ruf and his attorney said - it’s almost like the 2 aren’t quite aligned in their position.

Ruf describes this as a “hidden” hazard - while his attorney termed it an “obvious hazard”. The wording is key here as Ohio subscribes to what is called the “open and obvious” doctrine.

Usually it’s applied in slip/trip and fall cases - but it would seem to fit here as well. In short - if the hazard is openly visible to a reasonable observer or otherwise obvious - then the property owner duty to mitigate and protect and invitee is reduced.

Say your walking down a cleared sidewalk in winter on a freezing day - the property owner is not responsible if you slip on a patch of ice that developed from melting and refrozen snow it was open/obvious. Ditto walking into a fast food place on a rainy day where mats had been placed near the doors to avoid people slipping on the floor. It’s an obvious hazard that exist to protect people - so tripping on the edge of the mat because you didn’t pick up your feet isn’t the property owners fault.

This one will be closely watched - just because it could set precedent for future injuries at an athletic event. Think how many high school/college kids get hurt playing on turf for example - if he wins this how many will claim loss of athletic career/scholarship as a result of injuries sustained playing on turf vs grass fields? All it takes is precedent to be set and the floodgates open.
 

Archie

Archie

Joined
Nov 8, 2021
Messages
5,068
seems like it would be an obvious hazard that a groundskeeper or stadium employee operations person could identify .

but it's hidden to the players as they would have reasonable expectations that such hazards would NOT be present
 
Top