SMU deserves to get in over Alabama

[stormtrooper8]

Pretty clear

But feeling is committee will put Alabama in

 

[dougtushyterror]

Pretty clear

But feeling is committee will put Alabama in

Gonna really regret not pulling the trigger on this if that's case. Only concern was a close Clemson win which I read was the only way they keep Bama out & still put SMU in. Rn I'd still be nervous af if I bet this but I agree..Bama gets in.

 

[fishhead]

GEORGIA beating TX gets ALA in

 

[lekidecincinnati]

no way acc can get 2 teams in

 

[jjgold]

The whole thing‘s a mess that needs to be abolished

 

[palmettobeach48]

SMU is in or else teams will start opting out of Conference Championship games if they are ranked in the top 12 already. Would set a terrible precedent if SMU is dropped.

 

[patrickbateman]

Saban retired so he can start giving hand jobs to committee members.

Not enough money to be made off of SMU.

Scrap the playoff system. Go back to AP/Coaches polls.

 

[dougtushyterror]

SMU is in or else teams will start opting out of Conference Championship games if they are ranked in the top 12 already. Would set a terrible precedent if SMU is dropped.

Agreed..really should've gone for 2 despite the final outcome. Would've been harder to justify keeping them out based on a 50/50 play. They might still lose on a long FG but the fallacy of the predetermined outcome doesn't guarantee things would've played out the same way.

 

[charliebrown]

Agreed..really should've gone for 2 despite the final outcome. Would've been harder to justify keeping them out based on a 50/50 play. They might still lose on a long FG but the fallacy of the predetermined outcome doesn't guarantee things would've played the same way.

I thought they should have gone for 2

 

[teddyruxpin]

No

 

[djefferis]

Playing and losing a conference game should be a non factor.

If presented a 1 loss SMU and a 3 loss ‘Bama - which would you take ? I’d give the edge to a 1 loss SMU - granted they played a lesser schedule - but I’d give it to them over ‘Bama.

 

[Archie]

I'm torn

 

[fiftycint]

SMU SUCKS

 

[qurious$]

Pretty clear

But feeling is committee will put Alabama in

Yeah but Alabama is a touchdown better. So can't blame them for putting a better team into CFP

 

[Tanko]

The whole thing‘s a mess that needs to be abolished

Should we go with 64 team playoff?????

 

[jjgold]

Bama out

they can’t put anybody in with three losses

 

[Tanko]

S#it, pigs must be flying somewhere or hell has frozer over because, I agree with Stormtrooper on this one.

It should be SMU > Bama

 

[Franz555]

Pretty clear

But feeling is committee will put Alabama in

I agree with both Storm

SMU deserves the nod. Commitee takes Bama based on strength of sked

 

[stormtrooper8]

Yeah but Alabama is a touchdown better. So can't blame them for putting a better team into CFP

Not in reality

 

[BigJay]

I'm torn