Alabama/Notre Dame/Miami Which One DOES NOT Make CFP?

[Tanko]

IMO, it looks like two are in and one is out.....

Miami beat ND in week 1.
Bama w/ 3 losses but one loss is SEC title game.
Notre Dame played well all year after losing the 1st two weeks to Miami and Tx A&M.


Do they leave ACC out completely????
Does Bama deserve to be "punished" for the loss to Georgia?

 

[Tanko]

@BobbyFK @Wagerallsports
Can you guys add to the title of this thread and make it read....

Alabama/Notre Dame/Miami Which One DOES NOT Make CFP?​

I can't edit it.

 

[JDS]

Miami

 

[jjgold]

Miami and Notre Dame are two teams that actually could win the whole thing

 

[Tanko]

W

Miami

Wow... You think Miami is left out?
I like them. The have two losses and both were close (1 possession games) to Louisville and SMU.
I hope they make it.

 

[JDS]

W

Wow... You think Miami is left out?
I like them. The have two losses and both were close (1 possession games) to Louisville and SMU.
I hope they make it.

Somehow I read does instead of doesn’t

 

[JDS]

Oh well can’t change my vote now. It’s a real toss up for me Notre Dame with the slightest of edge. So I would pick Alabama.

 

[Franz555]

I misunderstood as well

I think Alabama and their 3 losses should be out. They play the games for a reason , so Miami beating ND in week 1 should matter. Miami and ND get in imo

 

[Tanko]

Oh well can’t change my vote now. It’s a real toss up for me Notre Dame with the slightest of edge. So I would pick Alabama.

I misunderstood as well

I think Alabama and their 3 losses should be out. They play the games for a reason , so Miami beating ND in week 1 should matter. Miami and ND get in imo

You can change your votes now....


Yeah the thread title sucks. I've asked mod to change it since we can no longer do it ourselves.

 

[Tanko]

I think Bama should be out.... 3 losses.
Sure their 3rd loss was in title game but they were beat pretty well in that game IMO.

Also, they could have moved up quite a bit with a win so they should suffer the consequences with a loss. Just my take.

 

[JDS]

You can change your votes now....


Yeah the thread title sucks. I've asked mod to change it since we can no longer do it ourselves.

Thanks Tanko.

 

[DiggityDaggityDo]

Everybody vote!

 

[Tanko]

Everybody vote!

View attachment 79957

Diggity just upgraded the thread.....
I may try and cut and paste this into 1st post.

 

[jamesy2422]

it should be bama but i think miami gets left out.

if conf championship games don't count the same, then they should not effect the record

 

[Tanko]

Here's one projection from USA Today Sports.
Bama would be out.

Indiana (13-0)
Georgia (12-1)
Ohio State (12-1)
Texas Tech (12-1)*
Oregon (11-1)
Mississippi (11-1)
Texas A&M (11-1)
Oklahoma (10-2)
Notre Dame (10-2)
Miami (10-2)
Tulane (11-2)
James Madison (12-1)

 

[Tanko]

ESPN's projections
Miami would be out.

1. Indiana (13-0)
2. Georgia (12-1)
3. Ohio State (12-1)
4. Texas Tech (12-1)
5. Oregon (11-1)
6. Mississippi (11-1)
7. Texas A&M (11-1)
8. Oklahoma (10-2)
9. Notre Dame (10-2)
10. Alabama (10-2)
11. Tulane (11-2)
12. James Madison (12-1)

 

[Pimike]

Miami

 

[BobbyFK]

@BobbyFK @Wagerallsports
Can you guys add to the title of this thread and make it read....

Alabama/Notre Dame/Miami Which One DOES NOT Make CFP?​

I can't edit it.

Done

 

[209life]

Take bammer out because of 3 losses. Put Miami in.

 

[jjgold]

You can’t have anyone in with three losses even with the extra game, it means those conference title games are useless. Why you even play them if they don’t count